Historic Homes & Homesteads · Colorado Springs

Homes That Tell a Story.

Some homes are just a roof and four walls. Others have 100-year-old hardwood floors, original plaster ceilings, and a front porch that's seen a century of Colorado Springs winters. Talisa McCarty specializes in finding historic homes, homesteads, and acreage properties — the ones with real bones and real character that can't be built new.

Book a Free Call Ask a Question

100+

Years of History

Colorado Springs has Victorian, Craftsman, and Arts & Crafts homes dating back to the 1880s. The ones that have been preserved — not flipped — are in a class of their own.

Acres — Room to Breathe

Black Forest, Peyton, Fountain, and Pueblo West offer genuine acreage — horse properties, outbuildings, water features, and space that a subdivision simply can't offer.

One

Of a Kind

You can build a new house. You can't build a 1903 Victorian. These homes hold their value differently because they literally cannot be reproduced.

Why Historic Homes & Homesteads Are Talisa's Niche

Talisa lived in a 1903 Victorian in downtown Colorado Springs for four years. She's toured some of the most unique homes in El Paso County — Craftsman bungalows in Old Colorado City, Mayan Revival masterpieces, Black Forest horse properties with 5+ acres and a barn. She knows what these homes are worth and what to watch out for.

These aren't cookie-cutter purchases. They require a buyer's agent who actually understands what makes them special — and what the inspection needs to catch. Talisa brings both.

Where to find them in Colorado Springs

Downtown Colorado Springs — Victorians and Craftsman homes dating to the 1880s, walkable to everything. Typically $450K–$1M+.
Old Colorado City — Bungalows, character homes, and historic storefronts. One of the most walkable and charming pockets in the Springs.
Manitou Springs — Eclectic historic homes in a mountain town setting. One of a kind.
Black Forest — 5+ acre tracts with horse barns, detached shops, MIL suites, and genuine privacy. About 15–20 minutes from shopping.
Peyton — Affordable acreage east of the city. Mountain views, room for animals and equipment, and a fraction of the cost per acre compared to Black Forest.

What Talisa brings to these buyers

Talisa has personally toured many of these properties. She knows what original hardwood looks like versus a cheap imitation, what a well-maintained septic system looks like versus one that's a problem waiting to happen, and what it costs to restore a 100-year-old home versus gut it. She connects you with inspectors and lenders who understand these property types.

What Talisa Specializes In

Downtown Historic Homes

Victorians, Craftsman bungalows, and Arts & Crafts homes in the heart of Colorado Springs. These walkable neighborhoods are some of the most in-demand in the city — and the homes don't come around often.

Homestead Properties

Acreage in Black Forest, Peyton, Fountain, and Pueblo West. Horse properties, livestock setups, outbuildings, and the space to actually live the life. Talisa knows what a good homestead looks like.

Restoration Finds

Homes with original hardwood, built-ins, plasterwork, and bones worth saving. If a property has been neglected but the structure is sound, Talisa can help you see past the cosmetics to what it actually is.

Rural Acreage

Water rights, detached shops, MIL suites, animal facilities, mountain views. The properties that simply don't exist in a subdivision — and that appreciation alone can't create.

Where to Find Historic Homes in Colorado Springs

Colorado Springs was built during the Pikes Peak gold rush era and expanded rapidly through the 1880s–1920s, leaving behind a concentrated band of Victorians, Craftsman bungalows, and Arts & Crafts homes that are genuinely hard to find anywhere else in Colorado. Here's where to look.

Old North End

The most intact collection of Victorian-era homes in Colorado Springs. Wood Avenue and Cascade Avenue are lined with Queen Anne Victorians, Foursquares, and Colonial Revivals from the 1880s–1920s. Expect original woodwork, stained glass, wraparound porches, and carriage houses. Typically $500K–$1.2M+.

Old Colorado City

Designated a National Historic District. Craftsman bungalows, Queen Annes, and working-class vernacular homes from the late 1800s and early 1900s. More accessible price-wise than the Old North End, with a walkable commercial district that's one of the best in the Springs. Typically $320K–$600K.

Downtown / Monument Valley Park

Weber Street and the blocks near Monument Valley Park hold some of the most architecturally significant homes in the city — late-Victorian and early 20th-century properties mixed with the commercial core. Excellent walkability. Typically $425K–$900K+.

Manitou Springs

Every house tells a different story here. Eclectic Victorians, stone cottages, and Arts & Crafts bungalows tucked into the canyon along Fountain Creek. The town has its own historic district and an aesthetic that doesn't exist anywhere else in El Paso County. Prices vary widely — and so does condition. Typically $350K–$800K.

What to Know Before You Buy

Historic homes and homestead properties come with considerations that standard suburban purchases don't. Here's what Talisa walks every buyer through.

Historic Homes

Lead paint — Homes built before 1978 are presumed to contain lead-based paint. Federal law requires disclosure and gives buyers a 10-day window to test. Intact lead paint is generally fine, but you need to know what you're dealing with before planning any renovation work.
Knob-and-tube wiring — Common in pre-1940 homes. No ground wire, degrades over time, and many insurance companies won't cover a home with active knob-and-tube or require replacement as a condition of coverage. A licensed electrician should evaluate it before you close.
Asbestos — Used in insulation, floor tiles, pipe wrap, and roofing materials in homes built before 1980. Intact asbestos isn't an immediate hazard, but any renovation that disturbs it requires professional abatement. Get a pre-purchase asbestos inspection on any pre-1980 home.
Foundations — Pre-1940 Colorado Springs homes often have stone, brick, or unreinforced concrete foundations. A structural engineer's inspection (separate from a general inspector) is worth the cost on any foundation over 80 years old.
Plaster walls — More durable and acoustically superior to drywall, but cracks and water damage can be significant or cosmetic. Learning to tell the difference is part of buying smart.
Historic district guidelines — Properties in designated districts (downtown, Old Colorado City) may have guidelines on exterior changes. Interior changes are typically unrestricted. Talisa verifies any overlay districts before you make an offer.
Renovation financing — FHA 203k and conventional rehab loans (like Fannie Mae HomeStyle) can roll purchase and renovation costs into a single mortgage if the home needs significant work. These are worth understanding before you start shopping.

Homestead & Acreage Properties

Well and septic systems: know the well depth, flow rate, and age. Know when the septic was last pumped and its condition. These aren't optional — they're deal-breakers if they fail.
Zoning: verify what animals are permitted and in what numbers before you fall in love with a property. El Paso County and municipalities have different rules.
Road access and maintenance: some rural properties have shared road agreements. Know who maintains the road and what it costs in winter.
Outbuildings: inspect barns, shops, and sheds the same as the house. A structural problem in a horse barn is an expensive fix.
Water rights: in Colorado, water rights are separate from land rights. Understand what you're buying.

Common Questions

What makes a home "historic" in Colorado Springs?

Age and character, primarily. Formally, the Colorado Springs Historic Preservation Office designates landmarks and historic districts — properties within those districts may have exterior design guidelines. But informally, Talisa uses "historic" to mean pre-1950 homes with original character: plaster walls, hardwood floors, original millwork, and bones that reflect how homes were actually built a century ago. These are different from a house that's just old.

Can I renovate a historic home?

Generally yes — but if it's in a designated historic district, exterior changes may need review or approval to maintain the character of the area. Interior changes are typically unrestricted. Talisa will identify any overlay districts before you make an offer, so you know exactly what flexibility you have.

What should I know about buying a property with acreage and a well?

A lot. The well's flow rate, depth, water quality, and age all matter. A professional well inspection (separate from the general home inspection) is essential. Similarly, septic systems need inspection and pumping history. Talisa always recommends these as non-negotiable add-ons for rural properties.

Are horse properties in Black Forest hard to find?

They move when they're priced well — often quickly. The right ones (good barn, solid acreage, usable pasture) don't sit. Talisa monitors new listings actively and will reach out the moment something that fits your criteria hits the market. Having financing pre-approved makes the difference between getting it and missing it.

What price range should I expect for a historic home in Colorado Springs?

It depends on neighborhood and condition. Old North End Victorians in good condition typically run $500K–$1.2M+. Old Colorado City bungalows are more accessible at $320K–$600K. Manitou Springs varies widely — $350K to $800K depending on size and state of restoration. Homes that need significant work come in lower, but require honest budgeting for what quality restoration actually costs. A cosmetic fixer and a structural project are very different financial commitments.

Are historic homes harder to insure?

Sometimes. Homes with original electrical systems (especially knob-and-tube wiring), aging roofs, or certain foundation types can complicate standard homeowner's insurance. Some insurers will write the policy but require updates as a condition of coverage, or exclude certain systems. This is one of the reasons Talisa flags these issues early — before you're under contract and running out of time to make decisions.

Do I need a specialist inspector for a historic home?

A general home inspector is a starting point, not the finish line. For pre-1950 homes, it's worth adding a licensed electrician to evaluate the electrical system, a plumber to scope the sewer line, and potentially a structural engineer for the foundation. It adds a few hundred dollars to your due diligence costs and can save you from very expensive surprises after closing.

What's the difference between a local historic district and the National Register?

The National Register of Historic Places is a federal honor — it doesn't restrict what you can do with your property. Local historic district designations (managed by the Colorado Springs Historic Preservation Office) may have design guidelines for exterior changes. The two often overlap but aren't the same thing. Talisa will identify which designation, if any, applies to a property before you make an offer, so there are no surprises about what you can and can't change.

Let's Find Your Perfect Property

Whether it's a downtown Victorian or 5 acres in Black Forest, Talisa will help you find the one-of-a-kind property you've been looking for.

Book a Free Call